URPG PokéMafia II (GAME OVER - MAFIA WINS)

Re: URPG PokéMafia II [DAY 1]

Don't be silly, people. Using the power can't exonerate or condemn him. Pidge is smart enough to edit a role that he can prove. If he does have the power, and uses it, it could still have a Mafia-related explanation that was edited out. Feng doesn't stay strictly to the rule-book when designing the roles, prolly... (I THINK. I DON'T ACTUALLY KNOW THE STRICT FUNCTIONS OF WHAT WE'RE ALLOWED TO POST IN THE MAIN TOPIC. THERE MIGHT BE SOMETHING PREVENTING HIM FROM DOING THAT, I GUESS.)

 

Re: URPG PokéMafia II [DAY 1]

I'll use my ability if most people say so and really needs me to do so. I planned on doing it when I had two solid lynches in queue, but oh well. My PM says it prevents all Pokemon from moving, so Feng, you better not have made some kind of retarded mafia role that actually has a priority higher than that.

Also, there is no way a night ender would be a mafia role, since it would be dumb for the mafia to not use their nightly kill.

So anyway, please respond if you want me to use my ability or not.

 

Re: URPG PokéMafia II [DAY 1]

This is why Scourge is right. Oh, and continue to suspect me... otherwise this post would look like I was trying to divert attention.

CONTINUE TO SUSPECT ME

 

Re: URPG PokéMafia II [DAY 1]

Dumb, but possibly strategic. See WTP's post. WE CAN NEVER KNOW WHAT FENG IS THINKING. :< If this role exists, he looks screwed whether he's mafia or not; if it doesn't, it could still just be a silly feature that had some strategic use he edited out of the PM, or it could be that he's innocent. WE CAN'T KNOW.

 

Re: URPG PokéMafia II [DAY 1]

Fair enough. So we get Gman out of the way. I still feel like WTP should be dealt with because of Yak stuff. If Pidge lied, we get rid of him next.

 

Re: URPG PokéMafia II [DAY 1]

So then today we choose gman or WTP or whatever. And tbh I think "wasting a night" is worth it if we can prove the innocence of one of the best people in the game, who'll play a central role in taking out the mafia (assuming he isn't mafia of course).

 

Re: URPG PokéMafia II [DAY 1]

Yeah, but we'd also be wasting a skill that, if Pidge is on Village's side, could be a helpful stall in the future. And like I said, it doesn't actually prove innocence. All it tells us is that he actually has the ability, not whether he's a Villager or a Mafia.

 

Re: URPG PokéMafia II [DAY 1]

Lives are being saved either way. Either the mafia gets a kill tonight or they get a kill in however many nights. I mean yeah it could be more useful later on, but we never used Jesse's power last game :S

 

Re: URPG PokéMafia II [DAY 1]

Pidge himself said: the game is large enough that there might be two independent Mafia groups. Which means that, if one Mafia group is trying to kill off the other, an ability like his could be useful.

So the point is that we're not actually gaining any logical proof of innocence (or guilt) by making him use his ability. So why waste an entire night + a potentially useful ability with it?

EDIT: Whoops, Stinky's post. We don't know the kill patterns of these Mafia yet. It's better to save this for when we know they're going for someone important and we need a night to stall and lynch, instead of just saving some random life that we don't have a tip on. This is a "crisis period" type ability, not a "look at the long run" sorta thing in its usefulness.

 

Re: URPG PokéMafia II [DAY 1]

That's what we're doing

 

Re: URPG PokéMafia II [DAY 1]

Well, we will be getting rid of an independent anyways. So I think it is a good choice, even if we lose a useful ability. I think Pidge himself is more useful than his ability anyways. So let's get this out of the way and figure out more later. Who should we have any night actions send to if they are able to move?

 

Re: URPG PokéMafia II [DAY 1]

Okay I gotcha

Also WTP jeeze why don't you only post stuff if you mean it? qq

 

Re: URPG PokéMafia II [DAY 1]

If you're going to continue doubting me after I use my ability and after everyone told me to do so, because there is a small chance that Feng could of gave it to the mafia, even though that would make no sense at all, you should reevaluate what the last line of your role PM says, and enjoy dragging down the village win. Unless of course your final line is different... And no, I can't prove myself 100% to be village, nobody can until they die or the game is over, but I can get pretty fucking close to it.

 

Re: URPG PokéMafia II [DAY 1]

This post was missed.

 

Re: URPG PokéMafia II [DAY 1]

I'm starting to think Pidge is just as suspicious as I am...

 

Re: URPG PokéMafia II [DAY 1]

<3

please bold your votes if I use ability or not

use it
don't use it

 

Re: URPG PokéMafia II [DAY 1]

Use it please.

 

Re: URPG PokéMafia II [DAY 1]

don't use it

It doesn't clear you, why waste it? Another thing that I don't think has been brought up is that everyone is trusting Pidge because he knows how to play the game and is a good player. He's a good asset for whichever side he plays. From the position he sits at right now, he could already easily allow a victory for either team.

 

Re: URPG PokéMafia II [DAY 1]

don't use it
Hurrah for sudden appearance.
Everything WTP said. I just... we don't know.

 

Re: URPG PokéMafia II [DAY 1]

Don't use
Because if the Mafia kills me, it's unneeded.