1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.
  2. If your account is currently registered using an @aol.com, @comcast.net or @verizon.net email address, you should change this to another email address. These providers have been rejecting all emails from @bulbagarden.net email addresses, preventing user registrations, and thread/conversation notifications. If you have been impacted by this issue and are currently having trouble logging into your account, please contact us via the link at the bottom right hand of the forum home, and we'll try to sort things out for you as soon as possible.
  3. Bulbagarden has launched a new public Discord server. Click Here!

invisible {halloweeb spoopyfest 2017]

Discussion in 'Stories' started by diamondpearl876, Oct 4, 2017.

  1. diamondpearl876

    diamondpearl876 Avid Bird Owner

    Blog Posts:
    0
    Joined:
    Jun 11, 2010
    Messages:
    2,219
    Likes Received:
    705
    CASH ATTEMPT
    for halloweeb spoopyfest 2017, category: best horror [ghost]
    cc: 6,619
    note: this is a heavily edited version of a one-shot i posted in the WW years ago. if this isn't okay, let me know.

    INVISIBLE
    I would have loved you, baby.

    The moment you pushed open the rusty metal door to my house, the moment your big green eyes widened in wonder, I knew I could love you. Honest.

    All you had to do to seal the deal was say yes, baby. And you were so, so close to saying yes. I’d been staring past the mold-covered windows, forever waiting, forever hoping for someone like you to come see me. It had been far too long since the last human dared to show themselves. Why couldn’t you have said yes, then, to cease my suffering? When you tried to leave, tears frolicking down your bloody cheeks, why didn’t you just turn around and embrace me? Why didn’t you take me with you and promise to keep me safe, keep me warm?

    I would have loved you, baby. I thought I’d made that clear. Did something about me bother you? Well, you rejected me and I had to cut you into pieces all the same. Did that bother you?

    Apparently, you missed the memo about how you can’t walk into an abandoned building and not expect to see ghost pokémon. It’s not a difficult concept to grasp. We live because there’s nothing else to do. The world won’t accept our departure, but likewise, its inhabitants won’t accept our presence. So we thrive where living souls usually don’t dare approach. There’s nowhere else to go until someone offers to promise to take us and keep us safe and warm from the dangers lying in wait for us. Someone like you.

    …Yet there very rarely is someone like you. Our solace rests with the sick scent of humans who have died here still lingering in these corridors. On the flip side, our afterlives are protected by human spirits which have no choice but to remain with us and fight the invisible fight against the living. When our home is threatened by other pokémon, we phase into the walls and peer through the cracks until the intruder scampers off.

    Humans, as you know, are a different story. Surely you could understand that we sometimes are scared, too, baby. Catastrophes are not quite as alluring as your spooky campfire stories would have you believe. Does that bother you? If it helps, I would’ve never been scared of you, baby. Honest. I would’ve never hurt you if you’d just embraced me the way humans were always meant to. Death is not the end. Death does not mean stopping, and death does not mean you disappear. Does that bother you, baby? Does it?

    We don’t embrace every human, mind. Some of my brethren wish to travel with trainers, as they seek the answer as to whether or not a ghost can be satisfied elsewhere besides the confined space they were chased into. We want to try to remember what it’s like to be part of teamwork and achievement. We want to be in the light once more. Does that bother you…? It shouldn’t, but I’d like to know.

    I would have loved you, no matter what we did together. Honest. Now, neither of us are leaving. You no longer have a say in the matter. You lost your chance to choose when you decided I was unworthy of your time and attention. You’ll stay and keep me warm with your ice cold bones the best you can.

    Your blonde hair was so pretty, baby. It was so bright, much too bright for a place like this. I pulled on it, forced you back from the door to my home, ripped it out. You held on to your head, though your hair was the least of your worries. Did that bother you? Your eyes were next. You crashed into the walls, screaming, scratching at them, lost. Oh, how wonderful it must’ve been to run into solid walls, a sure sign of the reality around you.

    Here’s another truth, baby: I wish I could figure out if I’m real or not. Did being real bother you, baby? If it did, I could’ve loved you and saved you. Instead I had to make you beg and scream more. For your mother. For your father. For your sisters and brothers. I made you beg and scream for the person you’d hoped to be by this point in your life. Does it bother you, baby, to know that you could’ve been waiting for the best day of your life, all the while never considering that it may have already passed you by?

    You screamed for your pokémon, too, baby. That was a real treat, I must say. They were waiting for the best day of your life with you, I’m sure. How disappointed they’d be if they left the comfort of their pokéballs and saw your mangled corpse splayed across at least a hundred others. They’d be angry, no doubt, but their moves would be powerless against me. They’d move right through my body, translucent as it is. They’d scream, too. So loud. I’d free them and allow them to take their anger out on me but it’d only make me miss your screams. I can never hear them again, and that’s such a shame, don’t you think, baby? I would’ve loved you and taught your pokémon how to fear and how to cry while they were still young. I could have taught them many things.

    I could have taught them in particular how there are many ways to end a life, making such a sacred concept even more fragile than expected and desired. There could be a simple snap of the neck. A disease which persists past modern technology to determine the day that you die. A pokémon attack gone awry and fired in all the wrong directions at all the wrong people. There could be the pull of a trigger and bullets that move faster than air itself, the same air that goes through so much trouble to place people in the gun's path, only to abandon them and watch them rot.

    Let it not be forgotten that blood—though you despise me for wanting it so much—is exactly what keeps both of you alive and breathing and together.

    Let it not be forgotten that you are trying to live in a world that can offer you nothing but misery not meant for someone so young, a constant fight against insanity, and a skeptical view on what it means to be happy.

    Let it not be forgotten that you made me this way.

    Does that bother you, baby?

    Baby?

    Why won’t you answer me?

    I would have loved you, baby. Speak to me. I am made of so much nothing, but I am not incurable just yet. I am floating on a slow, slow drift into indifference. I drowned and took one last short, terrible surge of breath in my past life and I just want to replace the memory. Please don’t let me go.

    Will my aching ever amount to anything? Will anyone ever fill the gap?

    …Baby?

    Okay. I understand. This is a kind of silence even a ghost roaming a cemetery is afraid of, but I understand.

    Humans are ephemeral. They come and go so fast and that sometimes I think that they are all the same. We come from two separate worlds, baby. But still. I would have loved you. I will love you now and forever, just in a different way.

    Let it not be forgotten that you made me this way. You deprived me of so much potential.

    I know it bothers you.
     
    Smiles likes this.
  2. Ralin

    Ralin New Member

    Blog Posts:
    0
    Joined:
    Mar 15, 2017
    Messages:
    64
    Likes Received:
    19
    C L A I M !
     
    diamondpearl876 likes this.
  3. Ralin

    Ralin New Member

    Blog Posts:
    0
    Joined:
    Mar 15, 2017
    Messages:
    64
    Likes Received:
    19
    INTRO


    Right off the bat, we get a grip of the narrator’s personality.



    Now, let’s look at the original line.



    Now, from the new one, we take the first sentence and leave that as the opener, letting the voice of the narrator sink in with one single line. In the original, you pour out the details of the story right away, revealing their murderous intent. With your new rendition, you leave that hanger there “Would have? What happened?” A small question like this is much more intriguing to the reader.


    -


    The first body paragraph of the new story shows a glowing personality that is definitely pushing the story onward at full strength. In a sick, twisted way, we see the mix of hurt emotions and creepy descriptions contrasting each other. Something pure and lovely: love, compared to something disgusting: blood running down the cheeks. This was a great way to open the story!


    The first paragraph of the original explores this concept, but compared to the original, it throws the message in your face. There isn’t some subtle quirk to the character here, it’s up front and feels a bit tasteless.

    You did a great job of changing it up!


    STORY



    I loved the repetition here!


    Compared to the original time using this line, you had it hang out away from the paragraph, letting the repetition and begging stand out. This was a great addition and made it feel so much creepier.


    -


    Next is the paragraph involving the “walking in” scene that had already happened in the first one. It shows how much more detail and effort you put in, also showing your growth as a writer!


    But, to be honest, I don’t think this paragraph was entirely necessary this time. In the original it seemed to set the scene, in this one it seems a little shoed in. I understand why you wanted to include it though, it helps transitions into the ghost’s explanation of longing, and why it loves this person. I think changing this paragraph up would have made it nicer, because there is definitely some important stuff here, it just is executed in such a way that don’t seem to matter as much.


    -



    This transition into the next paragraph feels pointless. I understand the use of it though. Granted, my perspective has me believe the previous paragraph should have been removed or changed, so keep that in mind.


    -


    I loved the additional explanations after that though in the new story, they really brought some nice depth and meaning to the concept of a ghost in your story. It’s really cool to see something that SHOULD be vicious, seen from a perspective like this. These paragraphs leading up to the hair scene, ( which is where these stories intertwine again,) really help flesh out the story in a way that makes this really stand out as its own unique story.


    The only one that felt weird to me was this one.



    I think the issue here is not the meaning of the paragraph, but it feels like the reader is missing a definite piece of the puzzle in the story. How did this person say no to the ghost?

    Mysteries are good, but if you’re going to explain pieces of the backstory like walking into the abandoned house, don’t leave the reader hanging!


    -

    These two paragraphs about the blonde hair are very much alike. What you did differently this time though was really nice and shows your growth. How you described the violent actions of the ghost are very clear, while in the original it feels vague. On top of the actions being more clear, they are very fluid and flow together, making this scene read very nicely.


    -


    This next scene is pretty screwed up, like, spooky screwed up. It really highlighted the tone of the story though, and was a huge shout to the world yelling “THIS IS WHAT IT’S ALL ABOUT!” Which is awesome!


    -


    The details on the hair pull are pretty much the same, just made much clearer in the new story. Again, growth. You could much better visualize the story and follow it along. It also was much less vague about things.


    -



    So, judging by the original, you were probably pretty proud of this line since you had it cut off from the rest of the paragraph. This is fine. But seeing it put together with the rest of the paragraph in the new story was much nicer and much easier to follow.


    Also, the exploration of murder furthers the spookiness of this tale. I love it!


    -


    The ending scene was really well done, but felt a bit weird coming from the perspective of a dead person, they know how things die, so why are they shocked to find this human dead?

    Otherwise, the new ending is about the same as the old one. You added many new details to it though which made that ending monologue so much easier to digest while reading. Nice job there!


    DETAILS


    It’s very obvious in the new version how much more comfortable with your writing voice you are. Like, insanely obvious. You didn’t hesitate to talk, use words to add personality, you just did it. The original had the narrator’s unique voice fade in and out. It existed, it just wasn’t entirely there. You really show off this comfortable writing with the ending. You put far much more time into making it build up. There wasn’t a sudden death then ending.


    Then, we have the mix of ethereal love and violence, a really great creepy mix. The only complaint I have here is that you mixed in the “filling of the void in my heart” with the love for the human. While it was a nice touch to explain the love, it detracted from the story’s horror aspects.


    Also, did this ghost know the human? It hints at it but I’m never sure.


    GRAMMAR


    I didn’t see anything here! Great job!


    LENGTH

    ACR: 6619

    Length meets the requirements for Simple - Cash.


    VERDICT


    Okay! So! This story’s mine shine as I have stated was the growth you had as a writer. The standalone story though. Was the gruesome scenery mixed with the innerworking of this ghost’s mind. It was a really cool mix of themes that really worked well in your favor! The best advice I can give you is sometimes it’s better to focus on less ideas and themes and make the ones that you do have really shine! Also, don’t leave such weird questions at the end, it made the world written for the reader feel more confusing than a “mystery.”

    Either way, great stuff here! It’s really inspiring to see someone grow as a writer so much in five years! SIMPLE CASH - 5k
     
    diamondpearl876 likes this.